Andina

U.S. judge favors ex-President Toledo remaining in prison

Photo: EFE

Photo: EFE

17:26 | San Francisco (U.S.), Nov. 13.

The United States judge —before whom former Peruvian President Alejandro Toledo (2001-2006) appealed a previous decision that had denied him bail while his extradition case is resolved— on Wednesday seemed in favor of the ex-president remaining in prison, although he has not made a firm decision yet.

Judge Vince Chhabria of the Northern District of California, based in San Francisco, closed the hearing explaining that he doubts between holding a new hearing —in which the evidence of the defense and that of the Assistant U.S. Attorney on the conditions of the imprisonment of Toledo would be contrasted— or definitely deny him bail.

This way, Chhabria did no longer put on the table the possibility of Toledo leaving prison immediately (something he could have decided today).

During the session, he seemed —more than once— satisfied with the Assistant U.S. Attorney's attitude, but especially belligerent with the defense.

The magistrate noted that —based on what he has seen so far— the Government has changed the game, adding that when Toledo was in solitary confinement, there were special circumstances that justified the bail. However, he noted, it seems that the Government has offered a reasonable alternative.

Suspense

Chhabria was thus referring to his ruling in early October, when —in an unusual move— he decided to grant bail to Toledo, but immediately put his decision on hold, with the aim of pressuring the Government to remove him from the solitary confinement regime, in which the ex-president was since his detention last July.

The reason why the former president is neither in the jail where he was before nor in the current one —under a common regime with the rest of inmates— is because prison officials consider that —given his high political profile— his safety may be compromised.


Toledo has spent the last two years as fugitive residing in Menlo Park, near San Francisco in the U.S. State of California.

(END) EFE/PBQ/MVB

Published: 11/13/2019